Which Form 4 buys count? Purchases against awards, exercises and plan trades

Updated

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Free on iOS and Android

A Form 4 reports more than trades on the stock market. Insiders must report each transaction resulting in a change in beneficial ownership of the company's equity securities[1], so a stock award, an option exercise, a gift and a purchase all arrive on the same form. What tells them apart is a one-letter transaction code on every line, and filers are told to use the code that most appropriately describes the transaction[2]. Who files a Form 4 and when it is due are covered in our guide to Form 4. This guide is about the codes, and about which of them are purchases.

The codes, grouped by what they tell you

Form 4's General Instructions list the codes under five headings[3]. Here they are grouped by what each one means for a reader.

Buying and selling: P and S

  • P, "open market or private purchase of non-derivative or derivative security"[4]: the reporting person bought.
  • S, "open market or private sale of non-derivative or derivative security"[4]: the reporting person sold.

Both codes cover private deals as well as trades on an exchange, and both cover derivatives such as options.

The company and its officers: A, D, F, I and M

These are the Rule 16b-3 codes[5]. Rule 16b-3 exempts certain transactions between a company, including its employee benefit plans, and its officers or directors[6] from Section 16(b), the provision that lets a company recover an insider's profit from a purchase and a sale made less than six months apart[7].

  • A, "grant, award or other acquisition pursuant to Rule 16b-3(d)"[5]: shares or options received from the company, which the rule calls "an acquisition from the issuer (including without limitation a grant or award)"[8].
  • D, "disposition to the issuer of issuer equity securities"[5]: shares handed back to the company.
  • F, "payment of exercise price or tax liability by delivering or withholding securities"[5]: shares used to pay the tax due when stock vests, or the price of an option exercise.
  • I, a "discretionary transaction"[5]: a choice a participant makes inside a company benefit plan, such as an intra-plan transfer involving a fund that holds company stock[9].
  • M, "exercise or conversion of derivative security exempted pursuant to Rule 16b-3"[5]: an officer or director exercising or converting a derivative, such as an option, in a transaction with the company.

Other derivative events: C, E, H, O and X

The form lists these for derivative securities, except for transactions exempted under Rule 16b-3[10].

  • C: conversion of derivative security[10].
  • E: expiration of short derivative position[10].
  • H: expiration (or cancellation) of long derivative position with value received[10].
  • O: exercise of out-of-the-money derivative security[10].
  • X: exercise of in-the-money or at-the-money derivative security[10].

Gifts, estates and the rest: G, L, W, Z, U, J, K and V

  • G: bona fide gift[11].
  • L: small acquisition under Rule 16a-6[11].
  • W: acquisition or disposition by will or the laws of descent and distribution[11], that is, an inheritance or a bequest.
  • Z: deposit into or withdrawal from a voting trust[11].
  • U: disposition pursuant to a tender of shares in a change of control transaction[11], such as shares tendered in a takeover.
  • J: other acquisition or disposition, used when no code fits, with the transaction described in the explanation of responses[12].
  • K: a transaction in an equity swap or a similar instrument, written beside the main code, as in "S/K" or "P/K"[12].
  • V: a mark in its own column for a transaction voluntarily reported earlier than required[12].

Why code P is what "insider buying" means

A line coded P records the reporting person buying a security. Its price is the price paid, per share, in U.S. dollars and without brokerage commissions[13]. Every other way shares arrive on a Form 4 is something other than a purchase:

  • Awards (A) are an acquisition from the company itself[8], not a purchase from a seller on the market.
  • Exercises (M, X or O) turn an option the insider already holds into shares: a disposition of the derivative in Table II, with the resulting stock holding in Table I[14]. The price shown is the exercise or conversion price, not a market price[15], and it can be paid with shares, which is code F[5].
  • Conversions (C) exchange one security for another, such as convertible preferred stock for common.
  • Gifts (G) and inheritances (W) move shares without a purchase.
  • Tax withholding (F) adds nothing: shares go to the company to pay a tax bill or an exercise price[5].

Each of these changes what the insider holds, and the holding after every reported transaction is on the form[16]. But only P is a purchase in the form's own terms, and a P line in the company's common stock is what people usually mean by insider buying. Even then, the filing does not say why. Table I has columns for the security, the dates, the code, the amount, the price, the holding afterwards and the form of ownership[17], and none for a reason; any explanation is in the footnotes.

Before reading a P line as a purchase of the stock, check the table (a P in Table II is a purchase of options or another derivative), the title of the security, which should clearly identify the class, such as "Common Stock" or "Class A Common Stock"[18], and whether the shares are held directly or indirectly.

Sales: plans, tax bills and diversification

Like a purchase, an S line carries no reason. The SEC's rules and rulemaking describe several reasons for selling that the code alone does not show.

Rule 10b5-1 trading plans

Rule 10b5-1 gives an affirmative defense to a person who, before becoming aware of material nonpublic information, had entered into a binding contract, given an instruction or adopted a written plan to trade[19]. The plan has to fix the amount, price and date of the trades, set a formula for them, or leave the person no later influence over how, when or whether to trade[20]. A director or officer must then wait out a cooling-off period before any trade: the later of 90 days after adopting the plan or two business days after the company reports its results for that quarter, and never more than 120 days[21]. Anyone else other than the company waits 30 days[22].

In December 2022 the SEC amended Forms 4 and 5 to require filers to identify transactions made pursuant to such a plan[23], for reports filed on or after April 1, 2023[24]. The filer checks a box for a transaction made under a plan intended to satisfy the affirmative defense conditions of Rule 10b5-1(c) and gives the date the plan was adopted[25]. The SEC chose the words "intended to satisfy" so that filers would not have to state definitively that a trade met the defense[26], so the box records what the filer says, not a finding. A plan can buy as well as sell: the box covers a plan "for the purchase or sale" of the company's equity securities[25].

Sales to cover taxes

When a stock award vests, tax withholding falls due. The company can withhold shares to cover it, which is code F[5]. Or an agent can sell shares to raise the money, which the SEC calls a "sell-to-cover" transaction[27]. Because vesting schedules are generally set in advance by the company, the SEC noted, the amount sold is determined by the value of the award and the taxes due on that value[28].

Diversification and cash needs

In the same rulemaking, the SEC recognized that limits on plan sales reduce insiders' ability to meet unanticipated liquidity needs, such as emergency or unplanned expenses, and can constrain portfolio rebalancing, diversification and tax treatment[29]. A Form 4 shows that a sale happened. It does not show which of these reasons, if any, was behind it.

Reading the rest of the line

Table I and Table II

Shares go in Table I. Options, warrants, convertible securities, convertible preferred stock and other derivatives go in Table II[14]. A derivative's own purchase or sale price goes in column 8 of Table II[15], so the price on a P line there is the price of the option or warrant, not of the stock.

Direct and indirect ownership

Each line is marked D for direct or I for indirect. Indirect means a pecuniary interest in shares held in another person's name, through a contract, understanding or relationship, including a family one[30], and each kind goes on its own line, such as "By Spouse" or "By X Trust"[31]. For a trust, partnership or company, the filer may report their proportionate interest or the entity's entire amount[32], so an indirect line can show the entity's whole trade.

Amendments

A corrected filing is a Form 4/A, and box 4 gives the date the original was filed[33]. It carries only the lines being added or changed, with footnotes explaining them, and does not repeat lines that are not being amended[34], so read it next to the original.

Late filings and Form 5

Some Form 4s arrive after their two business day deadline. A company must identify, under the caption "Delinquent Section 16(a) Reports," each insider who failed to file on time during the most recent fiscal year, with the number of late reports and of transactions not reported on time[35].

Form 5 is the annual catch-all. It is due within 45 days after the company's fiscal year ends and reports holdings and transactions not reported earlier, including small acquisitions and anything that should have been reported during the year but was not[36]. Since the 2023 amendments, a gift of shares, once allowed on Form 5, goes on Form 4 within two business days[37].

How GetSignal reads them

The insider trading page is rebuilt every night from Form 4s filed, normally, in the past 30 complete days across the companies GetSignal covers, and it states its dates. Its code applies these rules:

  • Only P and S count. Stock awards, tax withholding, option exercises, conversions, gifts and every other code are left out of the page's counts.
  • Only the company's own stock. A P or S line in options, warrants, notes, preferred stock or another share class is not counted as a buy or sale of the stock, and carries no dollar value.
  • Plan purchases are not buys. When the words on a code P line say a company plan bought the shares for the insider, such as an employee stock purchase plan, a dividend reinvestment plan or director's fees taken in stock, it is not counted as a purchase.
  • One insider, one row. A row is one insider at one company, their filings in the window added together. A joint filing that reports one transaction for several holders counts once.
  • A value only where the filing gives one. A dollar value is stated only when every line behind it has a usable price; a blank or zero price, or one far above the stock's close that day, leaves it off. The biggest-trade tiles also skip a filing priced under half or over double the company's 180-day median open-market price.
  • 10b5-1 only when the filing says so. A purchase or sale is marked 10b5-1 only when its Form 4 has the box checked, and the page shows what share of sales were filed that way.
  • The right company. A Form 4 is left out when the issuer on record for the filing is a different company.

The "Email me big insider buys" box on that page sends at most one email a day, on days an insider files an open-market purchase, code P, where the shares times the price on one line of the filing come to $1 million or more.

Each company page, such as /stocks/aapl, lists up to 20 of the company's newest open-market filings under Open-market insider trades: one row per filing, its tranches summed and priced at the weighted average, with the delay in business days and a link to the filing on SEC EDGAR. Awards, exercises, tax withholding, gifts and the other codes sit apart, under Other Form 4 activity. How GetSignal measures that delay, and the known limits of Form 4 data, are on /methodology.

This page explains Form 4 transaction codes and how GetSignal reads them. It is not legal or investment advice.

Sources

Citations (37)

Each bracketed number in the text points to the passage of the source it rests on.

  1. Form 4, General Instruction 3(a)(i): "Persons reporting pursuant to Section 16(a) of the Exchange Act must report each transaction resulting in a change in beneficial ownership of any class of equity securities of the issuer..."
  2. Form 4, General Instruction 8: "Use the codes listed below to indicate in Table I, Column 3 and Table II, Column 4 the character of the transaction reported. Use the code that most appropriately describes the transaction."
  3. Form 4, General Instruction 8, headings: "General Transaction Codes", "Rule 16b-3 Transaction Codes", "Derivative Securities Codes (Except for transactions exempted pursuant to Rule 16b-3)", "Other Section 16(b) Exempt Transaction and Small Acquisition Codes (except for Rule 16b-3 codes above)", "Other Transaction Codes".
  4. Form 4, General Instruction 8: "P, Open market or private purchase of non-derivative or derivative security; S, Open market or private sale of non-derivative or derivative security"
  5. Form 4, General Instruction 8, Rule 16b-3 Transaction Codes: "A, Grant, award or other acquisition pursuant to Rule 16b-3(d); D, Disposition to the issuer of issuer equity securities pursuant to Rule 16b-3(e); F, Payment of exercise price or tax liability by delivering or withholding securities incident to the receipt, exercise or vesting of a security issued in accordance with Rule 16b-3; I, Discretionary transaction in accordance with Rule 16b-3(f) resulting in acquisition or disposition of issuer securities; M, Exercise or conversion of derivative security exempted pursuant to Rule 16b-3"
  6. 17 CFR 240.16b-3(a): "A transaction between the issuer (including an employee benefit plan sponsored by the issuer) and an officer or director of the issuer that involves issuer equity securities shall be exempt from section 16(b) of the Act if the transaction satisfies the applicable conditions set forth in this section."
  7. 15 U.S.C. 78p(b): "any profit realized by him from any purchase and sale, or any sale and purchase, of any equity security of such issuer... within any period of less than six months... shall inure to and be recoverable by the issuer..."
  8. 17 CFR 240.16b-3(d): "Any transaction, other than a Discretionary Transaction, involving an acquisition from the issuer (including without limitation a grant or award), whether or not intended for a compensatory or other particular purpose, shall be exempt if..."
  9. 17 CFR 240.16b-3(b)(1): "A Discretionary Transaction shall mean a transaction pursuant to an employee benefit plan that: (i) Is at the volition of a plan participant; ... and (iv) Results in either an intra-plan transfer involving an issuer equity securities fund, or a cash distribution funded by a volitional disposition of an issuer equity security."
  10. Form 4, General Instruction 8, "Derivative Securities Codes (Except for transactions exempted pursuant to Rule 16b-3)": "C, Conversion of derivative security; E, Expiration of short derivative position; H, Expiration (or cancellation) of long derivative position with value received; O, Exercise of out-of-the-money derivative security; X, Exercise of in-the-money or at-the-money derivative security"
  11. Form 4, General Instruction 8: "G, Bona fide gift; L, Small acquisition under Rule 16a-6; W, Acquisition or disposition by will or the laws of descent and distribution; Z, Deposit into or withdrawal from voting trust" and "U, Disposition pursuant to a tender of shares in a change of control transaction"
  12. Form 4, General Instruction 8: "If the transaction is not specifically listed, use transaction Code 'J' and describe the nature of the transaction in the space for explanation of responses. If a transaction is voluntarily reported earlier than required, place 'V' in the appropriate column to so indicate... If a transaction involves an equity swap or instrument with similar characteristics, use transaction code 'K' in addition to the code(s) that most appropriately describes the transaction, e.g., 'S/K' or 'P/K.'"
  13. Form 4, General Instruction 5: "Prices of securities shall be reported in U.S. dollars on a per share basis, not an aggregate basis, except that the aggregate price of debt shall be stated. Amounts reported shall exclude brokerage commissions and other costs of execution."
  14. Form 4, General Instruction 4(c)(i): "Report acquisitions or dispositions and holdings of non-derivative securities in Table I. Report acquisitions or dispositions and holdings of derivative securities (e.g., puts, calls, options, warrants, convertible securities, or other rights or obligations to buy or sell securities) in Table II. Report the exercise or conversion of a derivative security in Table II (as a disposition of the derivative security) and report in Table I the holdings of the underlying security. Report acquisitions or dispositions and holdings of derivative securities that are both equity securities and convertible or exchangeable for other equity securities (e.g., convertible preferred securities) only in Table II."
  15. Form 4, General Instruction 4(c)(iii): "If the transaction reported is a purchase or a sale of a derivative security, the purchase or sale price of that derivative security shall be reported in column 8. If the transaction is the exercise or conversion of a derivative security, leave column 8 blank and report the exercise or conversion price of the derivative security in column 2."
  16. Form 4, General Instruction 4(a)(i): "Every transaction must be reported even though acquisitions and dispositions are equal. Report total beneficial ownership following the reported transaction(s) for each class of securities in which a transaction was reported."
  17. Form 4, Table I column headings: "1. Title of Security; 2. Transaction Date; 2A. Deemed Execution Date, if any; 3. Transaction Code; 4. Securities Acquired (A) or Disposed of (D), Amount, (A) or (D), Price; 5. Amount of Securities Beneficially Owned Following Reported Transaction(s); 6. Ownership Form: Direct (D) or Indirect (I); 7. Nature of Indirect Beneficial Ownership"
  18. Form 4, General Instruction 3(b): "The title of the security should clearly identify the class, even if the issuer has only one class of securities outstanding; for example, 'Common Stock,' 'Class A Common Stock,' 'Class B Convertible Preferred Stock,' etc."
  19. 17 CFR 240.10b5-1(c)(1)(i)(A): "Before becoming aware of the information, the person had: (1) Entered into a binding contract to purchase or sell the security, (2) Instructed another person to purchase or sell the security for the instructing person's account, or (3) Adopted a written plan for trading securities"
  20. 17 CFR 240.10b5-1(c)(1)(i)(B): the contract, instruction or plan "(1) Specified the amount of securities to be purchased or sold and the price at which and the date on which the securities were to be purchased or sold; (2) Included a written formula or algorithm, or computer program, for determining the amount... price... and date...; or (3) Did not permit the person to exercise any subsequent influence over how, when, or whether to effect purchases or sales"
  21. 17 CFR 240.10b5-1(c)(1)(ii)(B)(1): for a director or officer, "no purchases or sales occur until expiration of a cooling-off period consisting of the later of: (i) Ninety days after the adoption of the contract, instruction, or plan or (ii) Two business days following the disclosure of the issuer's financial results in a Form 10-Q... or Form 10-K... for the completed fiscal quarter in which the plan was adopted... (but, in any event, this required cooling-off period is subject to a maximum of 120 days after adoption...)"
  22. 17 CFR 240.10b5-1(c)(1)(ii)(B)(2): for a person "Not the issuer and not a director or officer... no purchases or sales occur until the expiration of a cooling-off period that is 30 days after the adoption of the contract, instruction or plan"
  23. SEC Release No. 33-11138, Summary: "Finally, we are adopting amendments to Forms 4 and 5 to require filers to identify transactions made pursuant to a plan intended to meet the rule's conditions for establishing an affirmative defense, and to require disclosure of bona fide gifts of securities on Form 4." The release is dated December 14, 2022.
  24. SEC Release No. 33-11138, Section III: "Section 16 reporting persons will be required to comply with the amendments to Forms 4 and 5 for beneficial ownership reports filed on or after April 1, 2023"
  25. Form 4, General Instruction 10: "Indicate by check mark whether a transaction was made pursuant to a contract, instruction or written plan for the purchase or sale of equity securities of the issuer that is intended to satisfy the affirmative defense conditions of Rule 10b5-1(c)... Provide the date of adoption of the Rule 10b5-1(c) plan in the 'Explanation of Responses' portion of the Form."
  26. SEC Release No. 33-11138, Section II: "In response to the concerns expressed by a commenter that the proposed checkbox language would have required a filer to definitively state that the reported transaction was in fact made pursuant to the Rule 10b5-1 affirmative defense, we have revised the text accompanying the checkboxes to state that a reported transaction is pursuant to a plan that is 'intended to satisfy the affirmative defense conditions' of Rule 10b5-1(c)."
  27. SEC Release No. 33-11138, Section II: "'sell-to-cover' transactions in which an insider instructs their agent to sell securities in order to satisfy tax withholding obligations at the time an award vests"
  28. SEC Release No. 33-11138, Section II: "Because vesting schedules are generally set in advance by the issuer, the amount of securities to be sold would be determined by the value of the award and the taxes due on that value."
  29. SEC Release No. 33-11138, Economic Analysis: "...expected to result in decreased liquidity of the insider's holdings, including reduced ability to meet unanticipated liquidity needs (such as emergency or unplanned expenses), as well as potential constraints on portfolio rebalancing and achieving optimal portfolio diversification and tax treatment."
  30. Form 4, General Instruction 4(b)(ii): "Securities beneficially owned directly are those held in the reporting person's name or in the name of a bank, broker or nominee for the account of the reporting person... If a person has a pecuniary interest, by reason of any contract, understanding or relationship (including a family relationship or arrangement), in securities held in the name of another person, that person is an indirect beneficial owner of the securities."
  31. Form 4, General Instruction 4(b)(iii): "Report transactions in securities beneficially owned directly on a separate line from those beneficially owned indirectly. Report different forms of indirect ownership on separate lines. The nature of indirect ownership shall be stated as specifically as possible; for example, 'By Self as Trustee for X,' 'By Spouse,' 'By X Trust,' 'By Y Corporation,' etc."
  32. Form 4, General Instruction 4(b)(iv): "...report the number of securities representing the reporting person's proportionate interest in transactions conducted by that entity or holdings of that entity. Alternatively, at the option of the reporting person, the entire amount of the entity's interest may be reported."
  33. Form 4, box 4: "If Amendment, Date Original Filed (Month/Day/Year)"
  34. Form 4, General Instruction 9(a) and (b): provide "each line being added" or "the complete line or lines being amended, as amended, together with one or more footnotes, as necessary, to explain the amendment of the line or lines. Do not repeat lines of transaction information that were disclosed in the original Form and are not being amended."
  35. 17 CFR 229.405(a): "Under the caption 'Delinquent Section 16(a) Reports,' identify each person who... failed to file on a timely basis reports required by Section 16(a) of the Exchange Act during the most recent fiscal year or prior fiscal years" and "For each such person, set forth the number of late reports, the number of transactions that were not reported on a timely basis, and any known failure to file a required form."
  36. 17 CFR 240.16a-3(f)(1): "The Form shall be filed within 45 days after the issuer's fiscal year end, and shall disclose the following holdings and transactions not reported previously on Forms 3, 4 or 5," including "(ii) Transactions that constituted small acquisitions pursuant to ยง 240.16a-6(a); (iii) All holdings and transactions that should have been reported during the most recent fiscal year, but were not"
  37. SEC Release No. 33-11138, Economic Analysis: "The amendments will require the disclosure of insiders' gifts of stock within two business days on Form 4. This amendment is a change from the existing rules that allow a stock gift to be disclosed on Form 5, which is required to be filed within 45 days of the end of the year during which the gift was made."
Company insidersOn GetSignal

The biggest insider buys and sales, from SEC Form 4 filings.

Insider trading

GetSignal appFree on iOS and Android

Follow any US-listed company, any fund that files a 13F and any member of Congress.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play